It got lost in the shuffle recently, but it was a move that
will have major ramifications to the kids of Jersey City for many years to
come.
The Jersey City Board of Education voted recently to
eliminate all freshman athletic teams in an attempt to save approximately $1
million in the district’s overall costs. In addition to slicing all freshman
teams, the Board of Education totally wiped away golf and bowling as varsity
sports, cut the number of assistant coaches for each athletic team and
eliminated any further spending in terms of new uniforms and equipment.
What that all adds up to is an absolute screw job to the
kids of Jersey City.
This move is an absolute disaster, both on and off the
playing fields.
First, from a competitive standpoint, how in the world does
a football program intend to get better without having a freshman team? How
does a player develop and improve without having a chance to be nurtured and
learn, playing and competing against kids their own age? Especially in a sport
like football, having a good freshman program is essential if you want a
varsity team to be successful.
Teams like Lincoln, Ferris, Dickinson and Snyder will be at
a disadvantage from now on, facing teams that had the benefit of a nurturing
freshman program. The Board of Education is essentially throwing these kids to
the wolves and asking them to compete against schools and teams that have solid
freshman programs.
Totally eliminating golf and bowling as cost-cutting moves
is just an imbecilic gesture. Especially now that there is a legitimate,
professional nine-hole golf course in Jersey City that could be used for
development. I remember the Lincoln golf team getting the chance to play at the
luxurious Liberty National Golf Course in the past, but I don’t think that was
a regular opportunity. However, the nine-hole course right off Route 440 is an
outstanding course and would have been a perfect locale for a Jersey City kid
to learn to play the game.
Not anymore.
And bowling? Are you kidding me? How costly is it to field a
bowling program? The teams are not big to begin with, with nine, perhaps 10
kids to a team. The people at Hudson County Lanes in Bayonne are glad to
accommodate the high school teams. It’s another move that made absolutely no
sense.
Some critics of the cuts have stated that it might lead to a
rise in the crime rate, that kids will have more free time on their hands and
get into trouble instead of playing sports.
That remains to be seen.
But just from a common sense angle, we should want to
encourage our youngsters to participate in sports. Playing high school sports
is a healthy, extracurricular activity that encourages teamwork and unity and
togetherness and camaraderie. We should do anything and everything in our power
to want kids to play sports, not take the chances away from them simply because
of budgetary reasons.
There should be a way to have the freshman sports continue.
There should be a way to have the kids who play golf and who bowl to continue
playing the sport they love. It should be a priority to keep athletics going,
not eliminated simply to make line items on a spreadsheet balance out.
High school sports are essential to the development of our
youth. Memories are made playing high school sports that last a lifetime. You
cannot put a price tag on the importance of high school sports. It’s totally
immeasurable, regardless of who wins and who loses. Just from the social angle
alone, high school sports are vital.
There should have been a way for the Jersey City Board of
Education to realize that high school sports should be a priority, not a line
item elimination. When a budget is introduced, high school sports should be
just as important as purchasing new textbooks or updating the information
technology in the school’s computers. It should be just as essential.
There should never be a day where the powers-that-be
determine that the way to have a budget more palatable would be to hack away at
athletics.
I have an idea. Why not start hacking away at the
ridiculously high salaries that the administrators all receive? Why not take a
few thousand away from those already collecting better than six figures in
their annual take?
That would be a better way of attacking a budget problem
instead of punishing innocent teenagers.
But of course, that will never happen.
If no one hears or learns of these cuts, then the Board of
Education will take the approach that no one is complaining about it, so it
shouldn’t be that big of a deal.
Guess what? It is a big deal. These cuts will be felt by the
results of the teams down the road, who simply cannot fairly compete against
other schools, programs and teams that field competitive freshman teams.
But these cuts hurt the ones that should matter the most in
the Jersey City Board of Education. These cuts hurt the kids, the ones we’re
supposed to be educating. How do these elected officials actually justify these
cuts? That they had no other choice? That they reluctantly had their hands to
the fire and were faced with the dilemma of finding the cuts from some place?
Well, athletics should not have
been the place where they looked to save a few bucks. Plain and simple, there should
have been a better way. These cuts were nothing short of moronic and simple
minded. Shame on the people who were elected and entrusted to take care of our
youth. They have basically turned their backs on these teenagers. It’s an absolute disgrace.
It’s only two weeks into the new NFL season, but the Giants
sure look like a complete disaster.
Thanks to new general manager Dave Gettleman and new head
coach Pat Shurmur, the Giants entered this season with eternal optimism that
Saquon Barkley was the savior at running back, that Eli Manning had found the
Fountain of Youth, that the newly formed offensive line was going to be
sensational and the defense would be revitalized and rejuvenated.
Well, two weeks in and Big Blue is a big mess.
Let’s start with the offensive line, because it’s probably
the most glaring problem right now. Gettleman and Shurmur were convinced that
Ereck Flowers would need nothing more than a shift from left tackle to right
tackle, that the former first round draft pick just needed a change of scenery
to jump start his career.
Well, on the first play from scrimmage this year, Flowers
was called for an idiotic tripping penalty. On the third snap, he was flagged
for holding. He’s been beaten at least 15 times in two games trying to make a
simple block and he’s whiffed badly, like Gary Sanchez wailing at an outslde
slider.
It’s safe to say now that Flowers is a complete bust. The
Giants would never say that they wasted a first round draft pick three years
ago on a guy who can’t play. But I’ll say it for them. Ereck Flowers cannot
play the game of football. He’s slow, clumsy, has worse feet than Herman
Munster, can’t block Betty White and worst of all, he will not admit to the
fact that he’s been absolutely lousy since he mistakenly put on a Giants
uniform four years ago. It would be easier to just cut bait, release him and
admit he was a mistake, but the Giants won’t do that because they don’t have a
viable backup on the roster.
Poor Eli Manning will have to continue to take the brunt of
the Giants’ mistake of drafting Flowers.
But Flowers is not alone with his horrific play thus far.
You have to wonder what In the world the Giants were thinking when they gave
Nate Solder a four-year, $62 million contract ($35 million guaranteed), making
Solder the highest paid offensive lineman in the NFL. Well, after two weeks,
that contract is downright offensive, because Solder has been dreadful. He’s
missed block after block. I can’t even begin to think what he’s graded out the
first two weeks, but it can’t be pretty.
The Giants drafted Will Hernandez in the second round to
play left guard next to Solder, giving the Giants what appeared to be a dynamic
left side of the line. But the rookie has been brutal as well, forcing Eli to
run for his life every time he drops back to pass.
The Giants have electrifying offensive players like Odell
Beckham, Jr., Sterling Shepherd and Evan Engram, but if Eli doesn’t have more
time to drop back and allow these receivers some time to get down field to run
their routes, their talents are wasted. Beckham was thrown to a total of five
times against Dallas. He has to touch the ball a lot more than that. Eli used the
safety valve so many times that Barkley set a new team record for receptions in
a game. The rookie had 14 catches. For 90 yards. That gives new meaning to the “Dump
down” pass.
Here’s my slap at Shurmur. Yes, he’s only coached two games,
but he made a glaring mistake in the Dallas game that I think changed the face
and complexion of the entire game.
Dallas scored the first touchdown early and led 7-0. The
Giants then got the ball and were moving the ball methodically up the field.
They get to just outside of midfield where the drive stalls, giving the team
fourth down and inches. And when I say inches, it wasn’t like a foot’s worth of
inches. We’re talking two, maybe four inches tops.
Instead of rolling the dice early, Shurmur elects to punt
the ball. It was a pooch punt by Riley Dixon (who looks like a keeper in the
early going) that gets caught for a fair catch at the 25-yard line, a 27-yard
punt that didn’t exactly pin the Cowboys back on their heels.
Shurmur had to go for it there. He did later in the game on
two QB sneaks by Eli that worked. But he
should have done it right there. It would have shown that he was in control,
willing to take a chance and shown that the Giants meant business. If it didn’t
work, then the Cowboys got the ball at midfield and the Giants would have to
suck it up a little and play a little harder.
But it was a chance for Shurmur to show he was in charge.
And he muffed it. The Giants had to go for it there. It changed the entire
game.
I could go on and on like Stephen Bishop (bad 70’s music
reference there) about the Giants, but I’ll say this:
They now have to win this
Sunday against the Houston Texans. On the road, against J.J. Watt and Jadeveon
Clowney and the Honey Badger and Deshaun Watson and DeAndre Hopkins. That’s a very good football team the Giants
are facing. Very good. Winning on the road in the NFL is never easy and beating
a very good team that is also 0-2 in their building is a pretty tall task.
So we will see, but I think it doesn’t look good for the
Giants this week.
I’m also going to say that it doesn’t look good for the Jets
as well. In fact, I think the Cleveland Browns’ awful losing streak comes to an
end Thursday night against the Jets. Just a feeling I have.
But the picture that is being
painted isn’t a rosy one for the locals.
You can read more of my stuff at www.hudsonreporter.com and www.theobserver.com